Home > Reviews > Douglas Alpine Review

Douglas Alpine Review

Derek Kikot
Mattress Expert
Last Update: November 18, 2024
Last Update: November 18, 2024
Methodology
Methodology

Product Research: Our Process

At Best Sleep Society, we carefully analyze mattress features to understand how they affect sleep quality. Our research process helps us evaluate comfort, support, and durability. This guide provides insight into how we assess the sleep experience.
Evaluating Comfort and Support
Our marking matrix is a detailed scoring system that evaluates each mattress based on critical aspects like comfort, support, durability, and temperature regulation. Expert sleep testers conduct an extensive analysis that considers various body types and sleep positions, ensuring comprehensive and relevant ratings for a wide audience.
Long-Term Performance Assessment
As mattresses age, they may undergo wear and tear, potentially affecting their initial comfort and support. To address this, our long-term analysis includes feedback from users who have slept on the mattresses for extended periods. This allows us to evaluate how well the products perform in real-world use and whether they maintain their shape, support, and overall quality over time.
Why We Look at Additional Services
In addition to our in-house tests and analysis, we thoroughly evaluate customer service, warranty policies, and setup and delivery ease. These factors play a crucial role in overall consumer satisfaction. A positive experience from purchase to longevity reflects a brand's commitment to quality and customer care, completing our comprehensive product research approach.

Douglas Alpine Mattress

Overall Rating
6.78 /10

Douglas Alpine Mattress

Price Range
$799
Mattress Type
Memory Foam
Firmness
4/10
Cooling
6.3/10
Pressure Relief
5/10
Trial Period
365 Nights
Warranty
20 Years
Support
6.5/10
Pros
Free bedding bundle
365-night trial
Cons
Diminishing edge support
Sinking feeling when sleeping
Mattress cover pills easily
Softer and more plush than they advertise

Construction

1. Douglas CoolSense® Cover

The machine-washable cover features Inifitex threads meant to keep sleepers sweat-free with a cooling surface.

 

2. 2.5” ecoLight® Cooling Gel Foam + Polar® Temperature Balancing

A layer of cooling-gel-infused memory foam.

 

2.5” Premium Elastex® Foam

Body-contouring memory foam

 

4. 7” Motion Isolation Support Foam

Foundational support foam

Comfort & Performance

 

Compared to the Douglas Original, the Douglas Alpine does not necessarily provide more comfort. Other than slightly more thickness in the foam, the construction is similar in every way, meaning any discomfort felt in the Douglas Original,  will be present in the Alpine as well. The lack of firmness puts this on the medium-soft side, whereas science suggests a medium-firm mattress is the best for appropriate back and neck support. 

Although the construction aims to balance body temperature and keep sleepers cool, our sleep testers experienced some heat and moisture, indicating the cooling properties were weak. What many testers disliked was the enveloping feel of the memory foam, with sleepers sinking into the surface, making it difficult to get in and out of the bed, and how they kept slipping and falling off the edges. If you aim to find a cooling mattress with good support and firmness, we suggest you explore other options. For example, the Silk & Snow S&S mattress is available in both medium-firm and firm, costs $XX less for a Queen, and offers better cooling and comfort. 

Motion Transfer

Our tests for motion transfer for Alpine indicated less motion absorption than the Douglas Original. While the Original performed quite underwhelmingly, Alpine had even more motion transfer. This suggests that you will experience disturbances in your sleep if you sleep with a partner or a pet.

Breathability

Douglas Alpine claims their “Polar Temperature Balancing” keep sleepers cool throughout the night, however, our sleep testers experienced a lack of breathability and airflow in this mattress. It retained some body heat and moisture, leaving the testers feeling hot and sweaty. We hoped the breathability of Alpine would be better, considering the mattress layers claim to cater more to hot sleepers. 

Conclusion

Despite the 365-night trial to test out the mattress longer, we strongly suggest our readers explore more options in the market before investing in Douglas Alpine. Firstly, it does not justify the additional $200 for the base model you pay in comparison to the Douglas Original, and secondly, this mattress raises concerns about its comfort and support. 

The lack of firmness, breathability, and motion absorption are reasons to avoid the Douglas Alpine, while the edge support is diminished over time, and the over-contouring feel of the memory foam can cause discomfort to many sleepers. 

For consumers looking for a mattress upgrade with a medium-firm, supportive feel and impressive breathability, we recommend Silk & Snow S&S Mattress

Please note: All prices referenced in this article reflect MSRPs and are accurate to the best of our knowledge as of November 18, 2024.

About Our Author

Derek Kikot
Mattress Expert
Derek Kikot
Mattress Expert

Derek Kikot has been in the business of sleep for 27 years, selling mattresses in stores and at home shows across Canada. With his decades of customer service experience, he’s finely attuned to individual sleep preferences and takes pride in helping each Canadian served find the best product to match their personal needs. As a parent himself, he appreciates the importance of a good night’s sleep!

People Also Viewed