Home > Reviews > Casper vs Logan and Cove

Casper vs Logan and Cove

Dr. Carmen
Board Certified Chiropractor
Last Update: October 29, 2024
Last Update: October 29, 2024
Methodology
Methodology

Product Research: Our Process

At Best Sleep Society, we carefully analyze mattress features to understand how they affect sleep quality. Our research process helps us evaluate comfort, support, and durability. This guide provides insight into how we assess the sleep experience.
Evaluating Comfort and Support
Our marking matrix is a detailed scoring system that evaluates each mattress based on critical aspects like comfort, support, durability, and temperature regulation. Expert sleep testers conduct an extensive analysis that considers various body types and sleep positions, ensuring comprehensive and relevant ratings for a wide audience.
Long-Term Performance Assessment
As mattresses age, they may undergo wear and tear, potentially affecting their initial comfort and support. To address this, our long-term analysis includes feedback from users who have slept on the mattresses for extended periods. This allows us to evaluate how well the products perform in real-world use and whether they maintain their shape, support, and overall quality over time.
Why We Look at Additional Services
In addition to our in-house tests and analysis, we thoroughly evaluate customer service, warranty policies, and setup and delivery ease. These factors play a crucial role in overall consumer satisfaction. A positive experience from purchase to longevity reflects a brand's commitment to quality and customer care, completing our comprehensive product research approach.
Hybrid mattresses are an appealing option for customers who are looking for the comfort of an all-foam mattress, matched with the enhanced support of coils. They offer a “best of both worlds” combining the benefits of both foam and innerspring mattresses, often at a price point that sits between the two. It’s a perfect middle ground for those who can’t choose between foam or springs! There’s a lot to know about these types of mattresses though, and a lot of options to choose from. We’re here to help guide your decision.

Two popular choices for hybrid mattresses are Casper’s Atlas Hybrid Mattress and Logan & Cove’s Frontier Hybrid Mattress. While on the surface, they may seem similar, our team’s testing showed they have some interesting differences that might be important to you. Let’s break it down!
Author's Pick
Casper Atlas Hybrid
9.14 / 10
Material
Hybrid
Durability
10/10
Cooling
10/10
Standout Features
• Value for money
• Cozy, knit cover
• Strong transition foam to reduce motion transfer and increase durability
Shop Casper Atlas Hybrid
Logan and Cove Frontier Hybrid
5.89 / 10
Material
Hybrid
Durability
4/10
Cooling
4.2/10
Standout Features
• Free bedding bundle
• 365-night trial

Which Mattress Should You Buy?

Casper’s Atlas delivers the Casper Signature Foam that’s known to be a high-quality memory foam in a hybrid mattress structure, and at a more accessible price point than some of Casper’s other mattresses. This combined with the transition foam and support foam give that comfortable foam feeling, while also eliminating motion transfer, molding to your body and maintaining the mattress’s shape over time. At the same time, its pocket coils bring extra support, including enhanced edge support to make it easier to get in and out of bed.

By comparison, Logan & Cove’s Frontier focuses more on coils than comfort, with a layer of micro coils sitting just below the mattress surface, and another layer of pocketed coils making up the base of the mattress. While all these coils do add extra support, our testers found they take away from the comfort, leaning the mattress more towards being a traditional innerspring bed. They also inhibit the mattress’s ability to reduce motion transfer.

So while both mattresses’ construction blends foam with coils, overall you’re getting a truer hybrid from the Casper Atlas Hybrid, with a perfect mix of comfort and support, as well as better motion transfer reduction.

Overview

Origin
  • Canadian company
  • American company with separate operations in Canada
Mattresses offered
  • The Casper Mattress (Comparing in this article)
  • Original Hybrid Mattress
  • Dawn Mattress
  • Atlas Hybrid Mattress
  • Snow Mattress Mattress
  • Wave Hybrid Snow Mattress
  • Logan and Cove Frontier Hybrid (Comparing in this article)
  • Logan and Cove Choice Hybrid
  • Logan and Cove Pinnacle Hybrid
Where to buy
  • Casper.ca
  • Casper stores across Canada
  • Sleep Country Canada stores
  • Loganandcove.ca
  • Goodmorning.com
Price
 Casper Atlas Hybrid (Queen): $1499 Logan and Cove Frontier Hybrid (Queen): $1299

Construction

Casper Atlas Hybrid
 

1. Cover: This cozy cover feels soft to the touch, and it’s stretchy enough to move with you. Plus it’s machine washable, making it easy to clean.

2. Casper Signature Foam (1.5”): If you’ve ever tested a Casper mattress, you’ll be familiar with this top layer of foam Casper’s known for, which is highly responsive to your every movement, cradling your body no matter what position you sleep in.

3. High-Quality Transition Foam (1.5”): This layer is designed to absorb pressure, giving you that “floating on air” feeling. It should lead to less tossing and turning, which will allow you to sleep deeper.

4. Pocket Coils (6”): This 100% steel coil layer is what differentiates a hybrid mattress from an all-foam one, adding in that extra support and bounce. In the Casper Atlas Hybrid, the coils around the edge of the mattress are a bit firmer, giving more edge support.

5. ProSupport Foam (1”): This is that dense layer of foam that gives the mattress the support it needs to maintain its shape through the years, without any saggy spots.

Logan and Cove Frontier Hybrid

 

 

1. Quilted Cover: The plush top cover with fibre fill contributes is meant to provide a cool-to-touch surface. 

2. ecoLuxe Cooling Gel Foam Layer (1”): The cooling gel layer aims to provide cushioning for shoulders, hips, and knees.

3. Aeroduct Micro Coils (1”): The micro coils are supposed to facilitate more airflow and contouring to your body.

4. Premium Elastex Foam (1 5/8”): This foam piece is meant to provide a balanced level of bounce while giving additional support and cushioning. 

5. Individually Wrapped Coils (9”): Pocketed coils across five zones are targeted for support in key areas of the body. 

Both mattresses contain five layers but with different compositions. Starting from the top down, Casper’s thick, top layer of its renowned Casper Signature Foam gives the cushy, memory foam feeling it’s known for. Logan & Cove’s counterpart layer is on the thin side and lends some cushioning effects.

The next layer is where they start to differ: Casper has a layer of transition foam to relieve pressure points, which should lead to a more restful and deeper sleep. Combined with the Signature Foam, you’re getting 3” of cushioning, giving the mattress that comfortable foam feeling that differentiates it from an innerspring model. By contrast, the Logan & Cove has a layer of micro coils intended to conform to your body and add more cooling. 

Underneath the Logan & Cove’s micro coils sits a couple more inches of foam that give some extra bounce, and then pocketed coils designed for zoned support. Meanwhile, the Casper’s base is made of 100% steel coils for enhanced firmness and bounce, as well as extra edge support. The edge support can be an important factor for those who need more stability when getting in and out of bed, or those who share their bed with a partner and want a more usable sleep surface around the perimeter. The bottom of the mattress contains an inch of dense foam to hold the whole mattress in shape.

In terms of firmness, Atlas Hybrid is on the medium-firm side while the Logan and Cove Frontier is on the medium-soft side. Medium-firm mattresses are optimal for supporting your back by holding your spine and neck in a neutral position, so Atlas Hybrid is the better choice here. 

Comfort & Performance

Author’s Pick
Casper Atlas Hybrid
Casper’s Atlas Hybrid Mattress has the exact benefits hybrid mattress shoppers are looking for: its three thick layers of foam deliver comfort and cushioning, just like you’d expect from a foam mattress. Meanwhile, its steel pocket coils give the firmness and support that inner springs provide. Those benefits combined make for an excellent example of a hybrid mattress.
Shop Casper Atlas Hybrid
Logan and Cove Frontier Hybrid
With two layers of coils sitting below just one inch of foam, the Logan & Cove Frontier Mattress leans more towards being an innerspring mattress. You won’t get quite the same level of comfort that having more foam leads to. While adding a second layer of thin micro coils is an interesting approach, our testers ultimately didn’t notice it made a difference in how the mattress feels compared to mattresses with the standard one layer of coils.

Motion Transfer

Something important to note about hybrid mattresses is that they generally won’t eliminate motion transfer quite as well as all-foam mattresses do, due to the nature of the coil layer. For those who sleep alone, this might not matter as much, but if you’re sharing a bed and are worried about your partner’s movements disrupting your sleep, it’s definitely something you’ll want to consider. The trade-off is that the coils provide more bounce, so while hybrid mattresses might not fully eliminate motion transfer, they will be more responsive. In the case of these two, both were able to reduce motion transfer, with the Casper Atlas Hybrid Mattress outperforming the other.
Casper Atlas Hybrid
Casper’s Atlas Hybrid Mattress has a transition layer specifically designed to reduce motion transfer, and this came through in our testing. While it doesn’t completely eliminate motion transfer (as is typical for a hybrid), it does do an excellent job of limiting it.
Shop Casper Atlas Hybrid
Logan and Cove Frontier Hybrid
Logan & Cove’s Frontier Hybrid Mattress has a layer of micro coils that are meant to contour to your body better, therefore isolating motion. However, coils tend to transfer motion because of their recoil, and this proved to be the case here. It had some motion transfer reduction, but not as much as the Casper Atlas, which has a thicker foam layer on top of its coils to absorb pressure.

Breathability

Another benefit of hybrid mattresses is that they’re generally more breathable than their all-foam counterparts, as the coils allow for more air to flow through the mattress. Here’s an important distinction between the two mattresses we’re reviewing: the Casper Atlas enhances the breathability already offered by its pocket coils by topping them with breathable foam, so the entirety of the mattress is designed to maximize airflow. Logan & Cove, on the other hand, took another approach with their Frontier mattress, opting for cooling features like cooling gel. The thing about cooling gel is that, while it may make for a nice cool-to-the-touch sensation initially, it typically fades fairly quickly as it begins to absorb your body heat. For this reason, I typically recommend prioritizing breathability over cooling, and that’s why the Casper Atlas wins out here.

Conclusion

Both mattresses stack up five layers of foam and coils to create a hybrid structure, yet they each bring a unique feel. The Casper Atlas provides responsive comfort, breathability, motion transfer elimination and enhanced support, while the Logan & Cove Frontier gives an initial cooling sensation, bounce and lots of coils.

It’s not surprising that Casper has nailed the hybrid mattress model, as they’ve been in this game a long time as one of the original mattress-in-a-box brands that now boasts more than 2,000,000 happy customers. They also offer a range of both hybrid and all-foam mattresses, all with Casper Signature Foam. (It’s worth noting that of their hybrid options, the Atlas has the most accessible price point, while still maintaining the same high-quality materials.) Logan & Cove only offers two mattresses, both hybrid options.

Casper has a faster shipping time, shipping within 1-4 business days compared to Logan & Cove’s 1-7 business days. You also have the option to test the mattress in-store at Casper and Sleep Country Canada stores across the country, whereas Logan & Cove is only available online.

Ultimately, we would recommend the Casper Atlas Hybrid Mattress over the Logan & Cove Frontier Hybrid Mattress because, for only slightly more investment, it better reflects the sleep needs hybrid mattress shoppers are looking to meet, with cozy comfort balanced by unparalleled support.

Please note: All prices referenced in this article reflect MSRPs and are accurate to the best of our knowledge as of October 29th, 2024.

About Our Author

Dr. Carmen
Board Certified Chiropractor
Dr. Carmen
Board Certified Chiropractor

Dr. Carmen Jweda is a Chiropractor and the Co-founder of NOMAD Pro Health, a corporate wellness company servicing working professionals. When she’s not in the office, Dr. Carmen is also part-time faculty at the Canadian Memorial Chiropractic College (CMCC), shaping the minds of future chiropractors. Recognized for multiple awards throughout her education and career, she extends her influence as a guest speaker on podcasts and at conferences sharing her expertise and insights. Given her clinical knowledge of how our bodies function, she recognizes the impact that quality sleep can have on our overall well-being. Dr. Carmen is a long-standing Endy partner and a happy Endy sleeper since 2020.

Best Mattress Overall
Casper Atlas Review
Casper Atlas Review

People Also Viewed

Endy Mattress Review
The Casper Mattress Review
Silk & Snow S&S Mattress Review - Firm & Original